Far West Realty - Rentals and Propery Management in Prescott
 

Screening Prospective Tenants - The Rest of the Story

Sometimes screening potential tenants can be as much art as science.  Far West Property Management in Prescott discusses issues encountered with tenants in Prescott.

More than once I’ve received applications from people who look like really good prospects – on paper.  But, as I mentioned in a previous post, “All that glitters, isn’t gold.”  Often, paper applications, no matter how diligently verified, just don’t tell the whole story.  That’s why, quite some time ago, I instituted a policy of never renting to anyone sight-unseen.  Just as I won’t rent a property to an applicant without the applicant having seen it, to make sure it really is what they are looking for, I also won’t rent to someone I haven’t met and interviewed.

Recently, I had one of my single tenants (I’ll call her Jane), propose, as a prospective roommate, an individual that was moving from another city to our town to take a job in the same office where my tenant worked.  Let’s call her Doris.  Jane had only met Doris once or twice and actually knew very little about her, but simply thought she seemed nice and would make a good roommate, since they would be working in the same office.

So, I told Jane to have Doris call my office to arrange for an application.  This was done, and Doris submitted her application.  When the final report came back from our screening service, it seemed on the surface like a decent report, not great, but not horrible. It seemed within the range that I might be able to approve.  When she and I spoke on the phone, I told her as much, but that I wouldn’t be able to finalize the application until I had met with her face to face for an interview, as was required of all my applicants.

She seemed a little surprised by that, but agreed to it.  Her only caveat was that she wouldn’t be able to come to Prescott Valley for that interview until she actually came with her moving truck loaded with her belongings.  I pointed out that, even though her current city was a couple hundred miles away, it would be in her interest to find a way to arrange an advance trip for the interview, since I could not guarantee approval, and that there was a chance that she could find herself being disapproved, with no place to unload her truck.  She said she wasn’t concerned about it, so I let it go at that. (Red Flag #1)

Several weeks went by before her actual moving day, and having expressed my concerns about what I thought was Doris’s poor judgement to Jane, and having received Jane’s assurance that she still felt good about it, I put the whole thing on the “back burner” until I heard further from Doris. 

Moving day arrived, and at the appointed time, she arrived at my office in company with Jane, for her interview.  The meeting began amicably enough, but as I asked her to tell me a little about herself, it became clear to me that she would not be a good fit at all for Jane, or the property. (Many more Red Flags) 

The more she talked, the clearer it became.  That, in combination with fairly minor concerns from her application, I could see that this roommate situation was likely to come apart very quickly.  I had seen it before.  And, when that happened, my client, the property owner, could easily have gone from having one very good tenant in Jane, to having two feuding, bad tenants, or no tenant at all.  I made clear to Doris that my primary obligation was to the property owner, and since I didn’t believe the proposed roommate situation would be in his best interest, I would not be able to approve her application. 

Predictably, she became quite irate, declaring that she’d never heard of anyone insisting on an interview before approving a tenant, and that she felt it was quite unreasonable.  Where was she supposed to unload her truck, or sleep that night?  I reminded her that I had warned her that this could be the result of the interview.  She said she knew that, but just hadn’t believed it would happen. All of a sudden I was a really bad guy, and her language went beyond colorful in expressing that sentiment.  She stormed out of the office in a huff.

I believe that was on a Friday.  On the following Monday, I received an email from Jane thanking me profusely for not approving Doris’s application.  She said it was apparent to her, not only from Doris’s behavior in the office, but in her conversation and behavior thereafter, that rooming with her would have been a disaster for Jane.  She was glad that my experience picked up where hers left off.

I tell this story to emphasize the importance of making personal interviews a part of the process in qualifying applicants for your rental properties.  A good paper application, thoroughly checked out, is essential, but by itself, may not tell the whole story.  Very often, the applicants will unwittingly tell the rest of it, if you will just get face to face with them and let them talk.  And more often than not, the rest of the story will serve to confirm the good things you’ve already learned from the paper application, and you will feel even better about approving them.  It’s worth the effort for that peace of mind alone, but doubly so if the in-person interview serves as advance warning of stormy weather ahead.

Call Dave at Far West Property Management in Prescott to find out how much we can do for you as your rental property managers, and at how reasonable a price!  Just dial 928-772-9400, and ask for Dave.

 

Posted to: Helpful Property Management Articles

 

All Blog Posts

 

Do you own rental properties? Learn the processes for property management in Prescott by Far West AZ

Far West Property Management on facebook
Far West Property Management on googleplus
Far West Property Management on youtube
Far West Property Management on tumblr
Far West Property Management on blogger
Far West Property Management on yelp
Far West Property Management on facebook Far West Property Management on google+ Far West Property Management on youtube Far West Property Management on tumblr Far West Property Management on blogger 
© Far West Property Management | Photo Credits | Privacy Policy | Website Design by iPrescott Business Solutions
Review:
"We have very much enjoyed our apartment as renters with Far West Realty for several years now, and are happily satisfied in our dealings with Dave Hamill and his staff...." read more
- Tammy and Jim
 
Review:
"Working with Far West has been a pleasure. Dave and his office were responsive to questions and needs throughout my three years leasing from them. ..." read more
- Jim Bogner
 
Review:
"Dave Hamill at Far West Realty was my property manager on a single family house for several years. As an out-of-state owner, I relied on Dave for everything: tenant..." read more
- Kent
 
Review:
"I have been using Far West to manage my rental in Prescott Valley for approximately 7 years. I live out of the area know that things are being taken care..." read more
- Korina Elliott
 
Review:
"Dave Hamill and his team at Far West Realty have managed our property in Prescott Valley for the past five years. It has been an all around pleasant and worry..." read more
- Terry & Carol Bourque
 
Review:
"Dave Hamill and his team at Far West Realty have managed our property in Prescott Valley for the past five years. It has been an all around pleasant and worry..." read more
- Terry and Carol Bourque
 
Review:
"Dave, Re: Our Experience with Far West Realty We have had an excellent experience with David Hamill and his staff at Far West Realty. The goals of the owners and..." read more
- Ken & Diana Turner
 
Review:
"We originally contracted with another Property Management house in Prescott, but they proved that they were incapable of doing even the most basic of jobs (like keeping the power turned..." read more
- David Hresko
 
Review:
"I was a commercial property manager/leasing agent for 26 years in Newport Beach and I well know that it takes some very special skills and abilities in order to manager..." read more
- Cathy M. Prescott, AZ
 
Review:
"I\'ve had Far West for my property management for several years. They take care of everything and send me a check! They schedule regular inspections so that I..." read more
- Theresa Williams
 
Review:
"I have been associated with Far West Realty since it opened. Dave has handled my properties and he is excellent. This is the third property management company I have dealt..." read more
- Jane Deleeuw
 
Review:
"Great, dependable, and honest people that meet the needs of their customers..." read more
- Alex Spence
 
Review:
"Prior to using Dave Hamill at FarWest, I went thru so many management companies. I have been with Far West for many years now! When Dave says he..." read more
- Bernadette Lafferty
 
Review:
"My wife and I have used Dave's services since we bought our property in 2011. As absentee owners, we were concerned about managing our rental property and Dave and..." read more
- Larry Blachut
 
Review:
"Best property manager in Prescott area. Dave handled all aspects of the Leasing and managing of our single family home As an out of state owner,..." read more
- Judy Rosenberg
 
Review:
"Far West Realty has been my property manager in Prescott for the last six years. Dave Hamill and his crew have done a good job for me. They..." read more
- Jim F. Austin TX
 
Review:
"David Hamill is very conscientious and professional. If you are considering Far West Realty for property management services, you will be pleased with their expertise, care, and attention.  Your financial..." read more
- Kent K. Newport Beach, CA
 
Far West Property Management 5 out of 5 based on 17 ratings.
Far West Realty in Prescott AZ - Homes for Sale | Buy Land | Property Management
5 out of 5 stars We have very much enjoyed our apartment as renters with Far West Realty for several years now, and are happily satisfied in our dealings with Dave Hamill and his staff. The very few concerns or problems we have had with our unit have always been met with real consideration and responsiveness. Further, Dave and his staff are readily accessible and always courteous. Tammy and Jim
Far West Realty in Prescott AZ - Homes for Sale | Buy Land | Property Management
5 out of 5 stars Working with Far West has been a pleasure. Dave and his office were responsive to questions and needs throughout my three years leasing from them.
Far West Realty in Prescott AZ - Homes for Sale | Buy Land | Property Management
5 out of 5 stars Dave Hamill at Far West Realty was my property manager on a single family house for several years. As an out-of-state owner, I relied on Dave for everything: tenant selection, lease negotiation, recovery when a former tenant didn't pay the last month's rent, cleaning, maintenance, marketing, managing repair work, etc. Dave and his team were always professional, courteous, competent, and just nice people. I wholeheartedly recommend them!
Far West Realty in Prescott AZ - Homes for Sale | Buy Land | Property Management
5 out of 5 stars I have been using Far West to manage my rental in Prescott Valley for approximately 7 years. I live out of the area know that things are being taken care of. I have complete faith in Dave and his team in the oversight of my property. They are thorough and very prompt in any given situation. I love the fact that I know that the house is being taken care of with TLC. You can't put a price on piece of mind and that is exactly how I benefit from using them. I would strongly recommend using Far West for your management needs. You will not be disappointed.